Super Lawyers
Justia Lawyer Rating for Ronald V. Miller Jr.
Best Law Firms
Avvo Rating - 10
Million Dollar Advocates Forum
Litigator Awards

Nursing Home Fall and Wrongful Death Lawsuit

Corby v. Brightview Fallsgrove

Hospice RoomThis nursing home wrongful death claim was filed in Montgomery County after a 100-year-old woman was found beaten and injured on the floor of her room. It was filed in Health Claims Arbitration on February 13, 2018, and it is the 75th medical malpractice case filed in Maryland this year.

Summary of Plaintiff's Allegations

A resident of the Brightview Fallsgrove nursing home was found by herself at the foot of her bed, beaten and severely injured. She sustained a scalp hematoma, soft tissue swelling over her right eye socket, buckling nasal bones, and multiple cuts and bruises to her face and wrist.

The exact series of events is unclear because it appears as though two Brightview staff members dragged the woman into her position at the foot of the bed and attempted a hurried cleanup of the scene. (Was this woman beaten? Was she assaulted by other residents? Was she assaulted by her caregivers? Is this even what happened or plaintiffs' lawyer hyperbole. We have no clue. This is a crazy story, right?)

Before her assault, the woman was alert, highly interactive, and mobile with the help of a walker. Her condition declined after the incident until she died of her injuries one week later, at the age of 100.

Additional Comments

    Throughout her report, the claimant's expert witness, a registered nurse, refers to the incident as a "fall" rather than "assault and battery." The official records and EMS report indicate that the woman was found lying on the floor after she had fallen out of bed and hit her forehead on the floor. But the woman's bruising and skin impairment was not typical of a fall, so state and county agencies are conducting further investigation into possible resident abuse allegations. There were no witnesses of the "fall."

    Even if there was no harmful intent and the woman did simply fall, the nursing home is still potentially culpable because they are responsible for fall prevention. According to the expert, a physician's order for wheelchair use was written the day before the "fall," but it was not signed until the day after the fall. Medical records give no explanation for the delay. The nursing home allegedly also had no fall prevention plan of care in place, even though the woman had fallen several times previously and was a known fall risk.

    The valuation of this case is going to be tricky. She was sent to hospice and died the next day. The cause of death was hypertensive artheroscierotic cardiovascular disease (HASCVD). So what exactly do we have on damages? A day of pain and suffering for a fall of unknown etiology? The defense to the case is going to revolve around the fact that this woman was 100-years-old. The plaintiff's nursing home lawyer should argue that if you make it to 100, you should die warm in and in your bed and not like that.

    The expert relies not on the nursing homes medical records but the reports of her "Power of Attorney" that the nursing home had no procedures. Nursing homes usually have procedures. In 2018, you can cut and paste procedures. They key is following those procedures. It not worth putting the expert out there on that evidence and she will get crossed on this at her deposition.

  • Montgomery County
  • Brightview Fallsgrove, LLC
  • Brightview Senior Living, LLC
  • The Shelter Group, LLC
  • Failing to provide adequate fall precautions for a high-fall-risk resident.
  • Failing to properly hire and train competent medical staff.
  • Failing to provide a safe environment for nursing home residents.
Specific Counts Pled
  • Negligence, Abuse, Assault and Battery, Medical Malpractice - Survival Action
  • Wrongful Death
Plaintiff's Experts and Areas of Specialty
  • Dawn M. Clunie, RN
Getting a Lawyer for Your Malpractice Claim

Have you suffered a hospital injury due to the negligence of a doctor? Miller & Zois can help you. Call us at (800) 553-8082 and speak to one of our medical malpractice attorneys who can help you or get an online case review.

More Malpractice Claim Information
Client Reviews
“When my sister was killed, we turned to Miller & Zois to fight for us. They stood by us every step of the way and we ended up getting more money than we asked for.” C.B. (Baltimore City)